An assessment that does not match your return is not the end of the conversation. Sint Maarten's General National Ordinance on National Taxes, the Algemene landsverordening Landsbelastingen or ALL, gives every taxpayer the right to file a reasoned objection, a bezwaarschrift, with the Inspector of Taxes. If the Inspector does not agree, the next step is the Court.

The process is not complicated. What catches people out is the clock, which starts on a date most recipients never look at, and the fact that objecting does not pause the bill. This guide walks through each stage in the order it happens, with the article of the ordinance behind each rule so you can check it yourself.

The Deadline: Two Months From the Date on the Notice

Article 29, paragraph 1 of the ALL gives you two months after the date printed on the assessment notice to file an objection. The same period applies to a decision of the Inspector that can be objected to, counted from the date of the copy of that decision that was posted or handed to you.

Two details matter here.

  • The date on the notice, not the day it arrived. The period runs from the dagtekening, the date the notice carries. If it sat in a post box for two weeks, those two weeks are gone. Note the printed date the day the envelope is opened and put the deadline in your calendar immediately.
  • If the notice states a period, read it. Assessment notices carry instructions on the reverse. Where anything on the notice suggests a shorter window than two months, work to the shorter one and ask the Inspector in writing to confirm. A deadline you met with room to spare is never the subject of an argument.

There is a second, less familiar route in article 29, paragraph 2. If you disagree with tax you paid yourself on a return, or with tax that was withheld from you, for example wage tax withheld by an employer, you can object within two months of the payment or the withholding. No assessment is needed for that route.

What a Valid Objection Contains

The ordinance asks for a reasoned objection, filed with the Inspector. A letter that only says you disagree gives the Inspector nothing to decide on. In practice a complete objection sets out:

  • your name, address and tax identification number
  • the assessment or decision you are objecting to, with its number and the date printed on it
  • the tax and the period concerned
  • which items you dispute and why, in plain terms
  • the figure you believe is correct, and how you arrived at it
  • copies of the documents that support your position
  • whether you want to be heard in person before a decision is made
  • your signature, or the signature of the person authorised to act for you

One objection should cover one assessment. Article 29, paragraph 3 provides that where a single letter covers several assessments or penalty decisions, the Inspector will give you the chance to split it into separate objections, and the separate objections are treated as received on the same day as the original. That protects your deadline, but it is simpler to file one letter per assessment from the start.

If the full reasoning is not ready before the deadline, file the objection in time with the reasons you have, and say that supporting material will follow. A late objection with perfect reasoning is in a much weaker position than a timely one that is supplemented later.

Proof of receipt

The Inspector must record the date of receipt on the objection without delay and send you an acknowledgement stating that date (article 29, paragraph 1). Keep proof of how and when you delivered the letter, and if no acknowledgement arrives within a reasonable time, ask for one in writing. The receipt date matters later, because it starts the Inspector's own clock.

Your Right to Be Heard

If you ask for it in your objection, the Inspector must hear you before deciding (article 30, paragraph 4). The Inspector may also call you in to provide information or to explain the reasoning behind the assessment. Any invitation must give you at least seven days notice.

A hearing is worth requesting where the dispute turns on facts that are easier to explain across a table than in a letter: how a business actually operates, why a payment was characterised the way it was, or what a contract was intended to do. Prepare for it as you would for any review. Bring the documents, keep your answers to what was asked, and confirm anything substantive in writing afterwards. Our guide to what to expect in a tax audit covers the same discipline in more detail.

How Long the Inspector Has to Decide

The Inspector must rule on the objection. Under article 30, paragraph 2, a decision is late if it has not been made within nine months of receiving the objection, and a refusal or a late decision is treated as a decision in its own right. That matters because it gives you something to appeal against even when nothing has arrived.

If the Inspector cannot decide within nine months, article 30, paragraph 3 requires a written notice to you explaining why. In cases designated by the Minister, the period is extended by that postponement, and the Inspector must still decide as soon as can reasonably be expected.

Where the objection is not upheld in full, the decision must give reasons (article 30, paragraph 5). Read those reasons carefully. They define the ground on which any appeal will be fought.

Objecting Does Not Pause the Bill

Article 32 of the ALL is short and frequently overlooked: filing an objection or an appeal does not suspend the obligation to pay the assessment. Collection continues on its normal course while the dispute is being decided.

Plan for that. If the assessment is large and you expect to win, paying and then claiming the refund is often less disruptive than letting collection steps run. If paying in full is not realistic, raise that separately and in writing with the tax collection office. The objection does not do it for you.

When the Burden of Proof Moves to You

Normally the Inspector has to support an assessment. Article 30, paragraph 6 reverses that in specific cases. Where the assessment relates to a return that was wrongly not filed, a required return that was not filed, or a failure to comply fully with the duties to provide information and keep records in articles 40 to 43, the assessment stands unless you show that it is wrong, and to what extent.

That is the single biggest reason objections fail in practice. A taxpayer who has filed on time and can produce organised records argues from strength. One who cannot is asking the Inspector to set aside an estimate with nothing to put in its place. Our guide to record keeping requirements in Sint Maarten explains what the ordinance requires you to keep, and for how long.

Costs of the Objection

Article 32a allows reasonable costs incurred in the objection to be reimbursed, but only where the decision was made in breach of the law through serious carelessness, and only if you ask before the Inspector decides the objection. Most disputes are ordinary disagreements about facts or interpretation and will not meet that standard. If you believe yours does, include the request in the objection itself.

Appealing to the Court

If the decision on your objection does not resolve the matter, article 31 allows an appeal to the Court of First Instance, the Gerecht in eerste aanleg, within two months of the date on the copy of the decision.

Where the Inspector has not decided in time, you can appeal against that deemed decision within twelve months, counted from the moment the nine month period expired or, where it was validly extended, from the end of the extension.

A judgment of the Court of First Instance can be taken further to the tax chamber of the Joint Court of Justice of Aruba, Curaçao, Sint Maarten and of Bonaire, Sint Eustatius and Saba. The judgment itself states how. In a published 2024 Sint Maarten tax judgment, for example, the Court set the period at two months from the date the judgment was sent and listed a court fee of NAf 300 for that step. Check the instructions in your own judgment rather than relying on another case.

The Timeline at a Glance

StepTime limitSource
Object to an assessment or decisionTwo months after the date on the notice or decisionALL art. 29(1)
Object to tax paid on a return or withheldTwo months after payment or withholdingALL art. 29(2)
Inspector decides the objectionNine months after receipt, unless validly extendedALL art. 30(2) and (3)
Appeal to the Court of First InstanceTwo months after the date on the decisionALL art. 31
Appeal where no decision was made in timeTwelve months after the nine months (or extension) expireALL art. 31
Further appeal to the Joint Court of JusticeAs stated in the judgmentThe judgment itself

A Practical Sequence

  1. Note the date printed on the notice and calculate the deadline the same day.
  2. Compare the assessment line by line with the return you filed, and identify exactly what was changed.
  3. Pull together the records that support your figures before you write anything.
  4. File one reasoned objection per assessment, within the deadline, and ask to be heard if the facts need explaining.
  5. Keep proof of delivery and chase the acknowledgement if it does not arrive.
  6. Pay, or arrange payment separately, because the objection does not stop collection.
  7. Diarise the nine month point. If no decision has arrived by then, decide whether to wait or to appeal.

Frequently Asked Questions

How long do I have to object to a tax assessment in Sint Maarten?

Two months after the date printed on the assessment notice, under article 29 of the Algemene landsverordening Landsbelastingen. The period runs from the date on the notice, not the day you received it. If the notice itself indicates a shorter period, work to that and ask the Inspector to confirm in writing.

Do I still have to pay while my objection is being decided?

Yes. Article 32 of the ordinance provides that an objection or appeal does not suspend the obligation to pay. If paying in full is a problem, raise it separately and in writing with the tax collection office.

What happens if the Inspector does not decide my objection?

A decision not made within nine months of receipt is treated as a decision. You can then appeal to the Court of First Instance within twelve months, counted from the end of the nine month period or of any valid extension the Inspector notified to you.

The Short Version

You have two months from the date on the notice. Put your reasons in writing, one objection per assessment, with the documents that support them, and ask to be heard if the facts need explaining. Pay or arrange payment separately, because objecting does not stop collection. The Inspector then has nine months, and the Court is the next step if the decision goes against you.

If you have received an assessment you disagree with, talk to us before the deadline rather than after it. Confirm the deadline on your own notice, and the current procedure, with the Belastingdienst or your advisor before acting on anything in this article.

Talk to CaribTax

Received an assessment you disagree with?

Two months goes quickly. We review the assessment against your return and your records, and prepare a reasoned objection before the deadline.

Book a Free Call →

Or call +1 721 554-8900

Sources: Algemene landsverordening Landsbelastingen, consolidated text in force from 31 August 2020, articles 29 to 32a; Court of First Instance of Sint Maarten, 7 February 2024, ECLI:NL:OGEAM:2024:2.

Disclaimer: The information on this website is provided for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal, tax, accounting, or professional advice. Rates, thresholds, and deadlines referenced are indicative and subject to change by the Sint Maarten authorities. While every effort is made to ensure accuracy, no guarantees are made regarding completeness or reliability. CaribTax and BrightPath Caribbean accept no liability for any loss or damages resulting from reliance on this information. Professional advice should be obtained before acting on any information provided on this website.